Letter to the Editor of the New York Times: City University: On the Need to Save John Jay and Hostos
Item
Letters to the Editor
City University: On the Need to Save John Jay and Hostos
To the Editor:
‘The Chancellor's proposal to merge
John Jay College with Baruch College
is based on an expected savings in
operating costs of the combined insti-
tutions. ‘Since the plan calis for a
continuation of the program in crim-
inal justice at the present Lincoln
Center campus at 59th Street and
Baruch College is located in the 23d
Street and Madison Avenue area, there
are grave questions about the reality
of those savings.
We have presented a plan to the
Chancellor and to the Board of Higher
Education which will match the $3
million savings the Chancellor would
achieve without destroying John Jay
College. The plan would reduce rental
space, cut administrative costs, in-
crease faculty productivity and reduce
staff. This proposal assures the con-
tinued vitality and viability of John
Jay College and gives the Chancellor
the savings we realize he must
achieve. To impose an artificial merger
of two geographically separated insti-
tutions is questionable at best.
Since John Jay is the smaller of the
two colleges, there is no question that
the vigor and excellence of this
criminal-justice quality program would
be jeopardized, John Jay College en-
rolls approximately 10,000 students,
and the cost. per student is the lowest
among the nine senior colleges in the
City University. John Jay is a low-
cost, high-quality college, directly and
constructively related to the City of
New York. There are over 4,500 police-
men, firemen, corrections officers,
FB. agents and other law-enforce-
‘ment men and women studying in our
unique curriculum.
In 1964, the Board of Higher Educ
tion founded John Jay College because
Xt clearly perceived the need for a
separate institution to study the press-
ing problems of crime prevention, law
enforcement and the larger questions
of social control and social deviance.
Prior to 1964, there existed a limited,
narrowly focused program in police
science at Baruch College. For years,
that program had been tossed from
location to location around the city
and given meager resources to develop.
It was only with the creation of an
independent college which has now
hhecome the leader and innovator in
the field of criminal justice in the
United States that the study of crime.
and its prevention was given its
necessary due,
‘To merge John Jay is to destroy the
educational vitality of the college.
Geratp W. LyNci
Acting President, John Jay College
‘New York, March 3, 1976
To the Editor:
Chancellor Kibhee of CUNY has
proposed closing Hostos Community
College in the South Bronx. This pro-
posal is senseless, cruel and destruc-
tive, No budget cut can justify closing.
an institution of higher learning which
has given so many poor people, so
many racial and cultural minorities
‘opportunities which otherwise would
be unavailable to them.
‘Why close a school whose small
size, personalized stracture and in-
dividualized instruction correspond to
the needs of students whose back-
ground has ill prepared them for aca:
demic work?
Why close a school which provides
the only possibility for higher educa-
tion for our residents whose main
language is Spanish? Hostos offers a
full range of courses in. Spanish ‘so
that these students may eam college
credits while mastering Engli
Why close a school which best
serves the working adults who return
16 school to improve their own and
their families’ lives? Half the students
at Hostos are over 27 years old.
‘Why close the only college in the
economically depressed area of the
South Bronx? The people here want
and deserve a college, and Hostos pro-
‘vides a learning and cultural center
Mostos Community College is too
important to he closed—too important
for the South Bronx, too important for
New York City. To close Hostos would
be to slam the door in the face of
those who as much as anyone deserve
education and jobs, and who have
een denied both too long. To close
Hostos is intolerable. PETER ROMAN
‘Chmn., Social Science Department
Hostos Community College
Bronx, Feb, 25, 1976
City University: On the Need to Save John Jay and Hostos
To the Editor:
‘The Chancellor's proposal to merge
John Jay College with Baruch College
is based on an expected savings in
operating costs of the combined insti-
tutions. ‘Since the plan calis for a
continuation of the program in crim-
inal justice at the present Lincoln
Center campus at 59th Street and
Baruch College is located in the 23d
Street and Madison Avenue area, there
are grave questions about the reality
of those savings.
We have presented a plan to the
Chancellor and to the Board of Higher
Education which will match the $3
million savings the Chancellor would
achieve without destroying John Jay
College. The plan would reduce rental
space, cut administrative costs, in-
crease faculty productivity and reduce
staff. This proposal assures the con-
tinued vitality and viability of John
Jay College and gives the Chancellor
the savings we realize he must
achieve. To impose an artificial merger
of two geographically separated insti-
tutions is questionable at best.
Since John Jay is the smaller of the
two colleges, there is no question that
the vigor and excellence of this
criminal-justice quality program would
be jeopardized, John Jay College en-
rolls approximately 10,000 students,
and the cost. per student is the lowest
among the nine senior colleges in the
City University. John Jay is a low-
cost, high-quality college, directly and
constructively related to the City of
New York. There are over 4,500 police-
men, firemen, corrections officers,
FB. agents and other law-enforce-
‘ment men and women studying in our
unique curriculum.
In 1964, the Board of Higher Educ
tion founded John Jay College because
Xt clearly perceived the need for a
separate institution to study the press-
ing problems of crime prevention, law
enforcement and the larger questions
of social control and social deviance.
Prior to 1964, there existed a limited,
narrowly focused program in police
science at Baruch College. For years,
that program had been tossed from
location to location around the city
and given meager resources to develop.
It was only with the creation of an
independent college which has now
hhecome the leader and innovator in
the field of criminal justice in the
United States that the study of crime.
and its prevention was given its
necessary due,
‘To merge John Jay is to destroy the
educational vitality of the college.
Geratp W. LyNci
Acting President, John Jay College
‘New York, March 3, 1976
To the Editor:
Chancellor Kibhee of CUNY has
proposed closing Hostos Community
College in the South Bronx. This pro-
posal is senseless, cruel and destruc-
tive, No budget cut can justify closing.
an institution of higher learning which
has given so many poor people, so
many racial and cultural minorities
‘opportunities which otherwise would
be unavailable to them.
‘Why close a school whose small
size, personalized stracture and in-
dividualized instruction correspond to
the needs of students whose back-
ground has ill prepared them for aca:
demic work?
Why close a school which provides
the only possibility for higher educa-
tion for our residents whose main
language is Spanish? Hostos offers a
full range of courses in. Spanish ‘so
that these students may eam college
credits while mastering Engli
Why close a school which best
serves the working adults who return
16 school to improve their own and
their families’ lives? Half the students
at Hostos are over 27 years old.
‘Why close the only college in the
economically depressed area of the
South Bronx? The people here want
and deserve a college, and Hostos pro-
‘vides a learning and cultural center
Mostos Community College is too
important to he closed—too important
for the South Bronx, too important for
New York City. To close Hostos would
be to slam the door in the face of
those who as much as anyone deserve
education and jobs, and who have
een denied both too long. To close
Hostos is intolerable. PETER ROMAN
‘Chmn., Social Science Department
Hostos Community College
Bronx, Feb, 25, 1976
Title
Letter to the Editor of the New York Times: City University: On the Need to Save John Jay and Hostos
Description
On March 8, 1976 the New York Times published two letters to the editor alongside each other. Acting President of John Jay College, Gerald W. Lynch, wrote to publicly oppose the proposed merger of John Jay College with Baruch College. He argued that such a merger was unlikely to yield the financial savings that elected officials sought, that the potential losses that would result were severe, and that there were viable alternatives to the merger that would avoid such sacrifices while achieving savings. In the second letter, Peter Roman, Chairman of the Social Sciences Department at Hostos, calls the cuts "senseless, cruel, and destructive." He names the many ways the college provides for the underserved community of the South Bronx and its Spanish speaking community.
In 1975, the New York City fiscal crisis led to efforts by city officials and the CUNY administration to close or merge multiple campuses in order to pay back debt owed to major banks. John Jay College was proposed to merge with Baruch College and Hostos Community College was slated to merge with Bronx Community College in order to dramatically cut spending. The proposals generated massive resistance on the part of students, faculty, and community groups.
In 1975, the New York City fiscal crisis led to efforts by city officials and the CUNY administration to close or merge multiple campuses in order to pay back debt owed to major banks. John Jay College was proposed to merge with Baruch College and Hostos Community College was slated to merge with Bronx Community College in order to dramatically cut spending. The proposals generated massive resistance on the part of students, faculty, and community groups.
Contributor
Meyer, Gerald
Creator
Lynch, Gerald W.
Roman, Peter
Date
March 8, 1976
Language
English
Publisher
New York Times
Rights
Copyrighted
Source
Hostos Community College Archives
Original Format
Newspaper / Magazine / Journal
Lynch, Gerald W., and Roman, Peter. Letter. “Letter to the Editor of the New York Times: City University: On the Need to Save John Jay and Hostos.”, CUNY DIGITAL HISTORY ARCHIVE, accessed March 10, 2026, https://stephenz.tailc22a4b.ts.net/s/cdha/item/661
Time Periods
1970-1977 Open Admissions - Fiscal Crisis - State Takeover
